HELP! Stuck in dead eye!

Hi! I'm playing RDR2 on PC and am at the end of mission 4 I believe. The dead eye update that allows you to stay in dead eye without tagged targets was introduced, I used it, but now I'm not able to deactivate it??? The wagon kept going but now it's stopped. I'm assuming the mission is over, but since I'm in dead eye the cut scene isn't starting. So I'm essentially in some sort of limbo where time has stopped and all I can do is shoot my gun, nothing else is working 😭

What can I do here? I've tried pressing allll the buttons but nothing works.